konversi_timezone(26 Jan 2021 22:57, America/New_York, 'full date') Market Execution: Why It Matters and What Brokers to Choose
R

Market Execution: Why It Matters and What Brokers to Choose



Jan 26, 2021   1271 
There are different types of execution in the forex market, in which market execution often considered as the better one. Why is that and which brokers provide this execution?

To access the currency market, you need to register with a forex broker. The primary function of a broker is to connect the trader and the market, as well as facilitate the trade and execute the orders.

Many brokers offer various types of trading accounts and other features such as leverage, spread, and minimum deposit. Every trader would have to consider these things before picking a broker as well as checking if the broker's legit and trustworthy.

But apart from those aspects, have you ever heard about market execution? Indeed, this feature is usually not displayed explicitly on the broker's website but rather discovered only after you explore the broker's specifications.

There are a few brokers that provide market execution transparently, here's the list:

  1. FBS
  2. IC Markets
  3. Exness
  4. XM
  5. OctaFX
  6. Admiral Markets
  7. Alpari
  8. FxPro
  9. FXTM
  10. ThinkMarkets
  11. FXOpen

So in this article, we will talk about the types of execution in those forex brokers and why market execution could be a better choice for you.

 

Brokers with Market Execution

The following brokers claim to provide market execution in some if not all of their accounts:

 

1. FBS

FBS is a renowned global broker that holds multiple regulations worldwide, including ASIC, CySEC, FSCA, IFSC, and FCA. Operating since 2009, this broker guarantees clients the fastest possible order execution speed, with 95% of orders being executed within 0.4 seconds.

All FBS accounts utilize market execution for orders, meaning orders are executed at actual market prices, and requotes are not possible. Orders are executed using NDD, ECN, and STP technologies, ensuring they are directly matched with the liquidity providers' systems.

 

2. IC Markets

IC Markets is one of the top ECN brokers regulated by ASIC and is widely known to have a good reputation among traders. Like FBS, the broker uses a market execution type that applies to all kinds of accounts.

Although the broker doesn't provide detailed information about this feature, you can check it directly on the IC Market's trading platform. The interesting part is the broker claims that they can execute the orders faster than other brokers because they use NY4 and LD5 servers.

 

3. Exness

Exness is a well-known broker that offers various types of trading accounts; some of them use market execution. The interesting part is that there is an account that can use instant execution and market execution at once.

 

4. XM

XM provides detailed information about their order execution types and even puts it on a specific page that explains that the broker uses market execution. Some of the advantages offered are no requote, fast performance, and orders are allowed even on weekends and holidays.

Because the broker doesn't mention if the execution type only applied to certain account types, so it can be considered that market execution is available for all types of accounts.

 

5. OctaFX

Based on OctaFX's official website, all account types use market execution with less than 0.1 seconds processing time. Like XM and IC Markets, this broker also offers three types of accounts: micro, pro, and ECN.

The minimum deposit for micro and ECN accounts is $100, while the pro account is $500. That amount may sound pricey, but the rest of the trading cost is relatively low compared to other brokers.

OctaFX doesn't charge any additional commission apart from the floating spread in the zero accounts.

 

6. Admiral Markets

Admiral Markets is another broker that provides market execution for all accounts. The broker's lowest minimum deposit is $200 USD. Some other features provided by this FCA-regulated broker are the add-on MetaTrader Supreme Edition, One-click Trading, Volatility Protection Settings, and Market Depth with Level II Pricing.

 

7. Alpari

Compared to the previously mentioned brokers, Alpari offers a broader range of account types. Unfortunately, only the ECN accounts use market execution. Despite the limitation, market execution in Alpari is quite reliable as the broker itself is supported by years of experience that prove its competitive edge.

 

8. FxPro

FxPro is an FCA-regulated broker that uses market execution. Uniquely, this broker doesn't categorize its accounts based on lot, spread, or execution type but focuses more on the trading platform.

You can get all the advantages of market execution in all types of accounts in this broker, especially in the MT4-based account that allows you to use both market and instant execution.

 

9. FXTM

At first glance, FXTM is similar to Alpari because both only use market execution for their ECN accounts. That is why this broker might be more suitable for experienced traders in terms of its market execution providing.

One can expect various choices of trading instruments if they open an account in this broker. After all, FXTM is well-known for its commitment to provide the most accomplished trading service for retail traders from the get-go.

 

10. ThinkMarkets

ThinkMarkets is the next Australian broker mentioned in this list after IC Markets. If you check the official website of ThinkMarkets, you won't find a specific page that explains the execution type used by the broker. They only wrote that they use the institutional model connected to the Equinix server's service.

As for the trading accounts, you can choose between standard and ThinkZero accounts. The difference between the two is quite apparent because, in the standard version, the minimum spread starts from 0.4 pips, while in the ThinkZero account, the spread can be as low as 0 pips.

Also, the operating balance in the standard account is 0, while the ThinkZero account sets the limit at 500.

 

11. FXOpen

FXOpen is mostly known to be the pioneer in facilitating Bitcoin CFD trading among forex brokers. This broker offers the advantages of market execution in all types of accounts except the micro account.

Spreads only apply to crypto and STP accounts, while the commission is charged in the ECN account ($1.5 USD standard lot) and crypto account (0.5% per half-turn). If you want to start small, you can choose between crypto and STP because the ECN account requires you to deposit at least $500.

It is important to note that there is a maintenance cost of $10 per month, and if your account is inactive, the broker can deactivate it and charge a $50 fee before a trader can re-activate it.

 

Types of Execution Order

In a broader sense, trade execution means processing traders' orders in the market. In this case, the broker should carry the orders to the market according to their role as the intermediary between the trader and liquidity provider in the market.

In the process, various things can happen. Did you know that sometimes an order can be executed at a different price than what is the trader intended? You may suspect that the broker's cheating or there's a glitch in the trading platform.

But they're not always the case. In fact, such a condition can sometimes happen because in the nature of forex trading, the price can change faster than the execution speed.

Moreover, there are two ways in which orders are executed, namely market execution and instant execution.

 

Market Execution

Market execution is a type of execution that fully relies on the available market price, so traders are only required to place an order and specify the volume of the trade. If there is a difference between the updated market price and the price at the time you ordered, the broker will automatically execute the order at the best price closest to your request.

In other words, your order will definitely be executed, but the price is flexible, depending on the market situation. The condition where the completed price is different than the asked price (it can be higher or lower than it should be) is called slippage, and this condition can occur if you use this type of execution.

The Advantages of Using Market Execution

  • Brokers are more likely honest and transparent because they use the market price.
  • Faster performance without any requotes.
  • It's possible to get positive slippage.
  • Orders will definitely be executed.
  • Mostly used by non-dealing desk brokers.
  • Low or even zero spreads.

The Disadvantages of Using Market Execution

  • Usually charges a trading commission.
  • There is no control over slippages, so it's possible to get negative slippage.
  • In some brokers, stop loss and take profit can only be added after the order is executed and the price is known.

 

Instant Execution

In contrast to market execution that executes an order based on the market price, instant execution will execute the order at the trader's desired price. So in this type, traders must place an order and specify both the volume and the price.

If the expected price is not available in the market, the broker cannot change the execution price. Instead, they can reject the order and send a requote to the trader, which then can be accepted or rejected.

To avoid requotes, some trading platforms provide the maximum deviation feature to set the maximum difference between the targeted price and the requoted price so that traders can adjust the tolerance limit at their desired level.

Keep in mind that even though this feature will not eliminate requote, it can help you control the execution at an acceptable price range.

The Advantages of Using Instant Execution

  • No slippage.
  • You can use the maximum deviation feature to avoid requotes.
  • Gives more control over when the asked price is not available in the market. Traders can choose to accept or deny the requote offered by the broker, even if that meansing the order.
  • Traders can set the stop loss and take profit before opening an order.
  • No additional commission.
  • The spread is usually fixed.

The Disadvantages of Using Instant Execution

  • Orders are not always executed; it can beed or rejected, especially if the price exceeds the maximum deviation.
  • It's possible to get requotes from the broker so that the order can beed, making it unsuitable for scalpers and news traders who need to execute orders instantly.
  • Used by the majority of market makers or dealing desk brokers.
  • Higher spreads.
  • Execution is not as fast as market execution.

 

How to Identify a Broker's Execution Type?

Now that we know the importance of a broker's execution type, how do we identify it in a broker? First, you can research the broker's official website.

Although the information regarding order execution is rarely displayed explicitly by the broker, you can dig up this information as a first step. A good broker would be transparent and very detailed in providing information about their services.

The second thing that you can do is to look at the MT4 Order Window. However, this method requires more processing time because you have to register an account and install the trading platform first.

On the MT4 Order Window, you can check the execution type as shown below:

Keep in mind that the information is not always accurate because only the broker knows for sure which type they use. Therefore, as a trader, you can also judge from your experience whether the broker acts in accordance with the execution that they claim or not.

You can also discuss it with other traders to identify which broker is honest and dedicated to their words. In the earlier steps, to anticipate the risk of getting a dishonest broker, you can read the review from other traders before you choose or start trading with a certain broker.

 

Conclusion

Based on the explanation above, the market execution type seems to have more advantages and a good reputation because it uses the real market price. The market price benchmark makes the market execution brokers more transparent, while in the instant execution type, brokers can easily manipulate the price.

But even so, it is not wise to think that all instant execution brokers are prone to cheating. Sometimes there is not enough volume by the requested price in the market, so they can't process the orders. This will then increase the number of requotes from the broker and could affect the quality of execution.

The truth is there are many instant execution brokers who genuinely want to develop their business in the long term and treat their clients as best as they can, especially those who are already licensed by credible regulatory bodies.

That is why instant execution brokers still exist and are quite popular in the forex trading industry, despite the general perception that favors the market execution brokers. When it comes to choosing the best type, you need to consider both types' advantages and disadvantages.

A hybrid broker usually provides two execution models in two separate account types. For example, on the cent and standard accounts, a broker uses instant execution, while on the ECN accounts, it uses market execution.

Still curious about the other brokers? You can compare them using the forex broker comparison tool.