R

Which is Better, Raw Spread or Standard Trading Account?



Dec 31, 2020   22603 
Main differences between raw spread trading account and standard trading account lie in trading costs, namely spread and commission fees.

Many forex brokers nowadays provide several types of trading account. Two of the most popular offerings are raw spread trading account and standard trading account.

Actually, each forex broker may establish different terms and conditions for their trading accounts. This makes it difficult to decide which type of account is better without knowing in which broker you are going to open the accounts.

However, if you're a scalper, a raw spread account might be better. If you're a swing trader or position trader, then standard account might be recommended. Still, we could compare general circumstances of raw spread vs standard account apart from those specific terms.

 

Raw Spread vs Standard Account Comparison

Take a look at the following table to simplify your understanding of the raw spread and standard account types:

  Raw Spread Account Standard Account
Asset prices Real market prices Already added the broker's markup fees
Spread Extremely low or even zero Usually higher
Commission Commissions tend to be high Cheaper to zero commissions

You can see from the table above, raw spread trading account, also often called an ECN account, offers real market prices for all instruments. Forex brokers will not add any markup on asset prices, so spreads usually are extremely low or even zero.

However, traders have to pay a higher commission fee for each trade executed. Some forex brokers charge the fees for each opening and closing trade ("per side"), while some others may charge fees after one full round-turn.

A standard trading account offers asset prices that have been added a certain amount of markup by the broker. Spreads are usually higher, while commission fee for each trade will be cheaper or even free.

For example, let's assume you want to buy the EUR/USD which is currently traded at 1.2100. If you have a raw spread account, you will probably be able to buy it at 1.2100.

As soon as the price rises to any level, you can close the position with considerable profit (although you have to make sure the gain will offset the commission fee as well).

If you have a standard trading account, you probably could only buy it at an ask price of 1.2102. It means you are going to incur a loss of 2 pips as soon as you entered the trade.

This is what everybody calls a spread. In order to close the trade in the green, EUR/USD has to rise at least 3 pips. Even so, your profit will always be 2 pips less than what it should be.

Spreads calculation is usually automated so you don't have to count it every single time you open a trade.

 

Raw Spread and Standard Account in Brokers 

You can compare both spread and commission fees that are charged by your chosen broker to make sure which one will incur lower costs for your trading strategies.

For example, IC Markets, a pioneer who popularized the term "raw spread" throughout the world. The Australian-licensed forex broker provides Raw Spread Trading Account with spreads starting from 0 pip and commission fees of $3.0 per standard lot.

IC Markets also offers Standard Trading Account with zero commission and spread starting from 1.0 pip. Both could be opened with a starting deposit as low as USD200.

Its fellow Australian forex broker, Pepperstone, also offers both raw spread (under the name "Razor Account") and Standard Account for retail traders.

Pepperstone's Razor Account provides institutional grade spreads without markup (average EUR/USD spread at 0.0 - 0.3 pips) and commission starting from $7 for each 100k traded per round turn.

While Standard Account charges spread around 1.0 - 1.3 pips and zero commission fees.

 

So, Which One Do You Think is Better?

Every trader may have a different opinion in accordance with their own trading style. If you are a scalper and need to profit from minor changes in asset prices, the raw spread trading account might be more suitable.

But if you are a swing trader or position trader, the standard trading account might be more advantageous. Actually, applying a longer-term strategy can give you more freedom in choosing trading accounts; you're not bound to pick the one with the most accurate pricing, unlike short-term strategies which highly depend on it.

 

If you're a UK trader, finding a good raw spread providers can be tricky. To anticipate false claims from unreliable brokers, you can refer to these top raw spread brokers in the UK.


19 Comments

David Elstob

Mar 29 2021

Spreads are next to nothing on the majors, so the big plus I can see is if you're a professional is for trading exotics, then the Razor account would make sense?

Obviously exotics - especially volatile ones - can have huge spreads on a standard account.

Aisha

Sep 7 2021

Yes, that is correct. I see most traders who prefer raw spread accounts are professionals.

Torima

Feb 24 2023

Aisha: I just got here and am a bit confused as to why the ECN account is similar to the Raw Spread account. Meanwhile the Raw Spread account itself offers lower spreads than the Standard account. And what surprised me is that standard accounts have higher spreads, which may be a burden for some traders. In the meantime, of course, as a beginner, you should trade wisely and trade with a little less commission that you may incur while trading. And of course, with slightly lower fees, you can trade with a little peace of mind

What is the reason that most novice traders trade on standard accounts instead of raw spread accounts? Thank you very much! 

Ansu Fati

Feb 24 2023

Torima: In my opinion, the ECN account especially at commission can be higher than standard account. Since it is very normal for broker to charge higher commission if they offered lowest spread. I think they do that in order to balance their profit after giving very low spread.

About the ECN itself, I do admit that spread in there can be very low and stabil. but if you don`t trade carefully at there, and especially traders who open more higher volume, may suffer the commissions. Though want to avoid some spread, you need to face the big commission too

Since the ECN acccount more prefered by pro especially scalper and EA trading, standard account may offer most simple trading condition that may suitable for novice 

Dakota Ross

Apr 11 2022

As long as you have enough money, any type of account should not be a problem. Am I right? LOL.

Bill

Jan 2 2023

Dakota Ross: No, it is not only about your fund. Spreads can have a significant impact on trading results as they can be calculated while a trading position is open. If you are a scalper then if you open and trade a lot of positions in the same timeframe and open a standard account and do scalping.Most of the standard accounts spreads can be at least 1 pip so profit is definitely below target. So, if you open 20 positions, you will be charged 20 pips ($20). But, for example, if you open an account with RAW spreads where spreads start at 0 points, you will be charged 0.1 x 20 positions, only 2 pips, which could be as low as $2. SO, what's most important is how your strategy will suit you and your trading condition.
Novi

Jan 2 2023

Bill: For the note, the RAW account may sound cheaper than standard account but for the commision can higher than you expected and yet- it still will cheap since you need to trade up to 1 lot. But if you get higher floating rate due to the market, some pairs can floating spread that sometime at RAW account can float higher making the spread become more expensive and can change your profit target result that you want. So always to check the floating spread first before trading
Josh

Feb 24 2023

Dakota Ross: Agree! Believe it or not, if you can manage your risk management, a demo account will help you learn all about Forex and be ready to trade live. If a trader with little money had more success in trading that could lead to limited profits, if he had a lot of money and could use it wisely, what would forex trading look like? it will be freer to open position without need to be fear about the floating loss either. Because forex itself requires more money to trade more freely. If you have $100,000 and trade 0.01 lots with leverage of 1:100; Trade Forex with as little as $100 and you'll feel a really different trade. 

Roger

Apr 12 2022

I'm still confused about the difference between PAMM account and Managed account. In general, though, the meaning is the same. Explanation on Pepperstone table why do you have PAMM checked but not on Managed account?

Hunter

Apr 13 2022

Roger: It seems the information from this website needs to be updated because on the Peppertone website it is explained that they accept PAMM or MAM accounts. You can check it via this link.

Anita

Jan 2 2023

Roger: PAMM account is an account that make Investor can allocation their funds to fund manager to optimized what their invest. But at managed account you can do the same thing but your fund will be executed by other trader that have good performance in trading or even EA. So, basicly PAMM managed by fund manager meanwhile managed account by other trader. Because of that, this two things are completly different.
Yoga

Feb 24 2023

Anita: No, I think you need to read more. I do agree about the PAMM explanation, which is very completed and clear. But I want to say that basically, a managed account is an account type that allows another trader to manage your trades. In fact, one of the types of managed accounts is the PAMM account.

So basically, PAMM and any other type of account can be managed by someone else, most of them are manager money or normally you can call it Managed Account.

And I think the post needs editing about the X in the managed account. 

Patricia Anderson

Apr 18 2022

I am today years old to know that raw spread is actually an ECN account? Why do I always think that they are different?

John

Jan 2 2023

Patricia Anderson: actually the ECN account can be called Raw ECN Account as well. I also dont know about the different of RAW Spread and ECN Account but for the sure, all of these terms all allowing you to get benefit of trading by 0 spread which is we can feel the trading environment almost without fees at opening position.
Marie

Feb 24 2023

John: I totally disagree. In fact, many STP type brokers can offer functionality similar to ECN accounts. Some of them may have advanced servers that can process orders faster and may even offer lower spreads than standard STP accounts. Eve, the brokers also call the account with Raw Zero Spread or Raw Spread account, but the spread can be slightly higher than the ECN account.

Aside from that, the fees charged seem to be similar. The best thing about an ECN account is that it offers features such as Depth of Market that allow you to see the actual state of the market which STP broker cannot provide.

Angela Thomas

Nov 20 2022

In order to close the trade in the green, EUR/USD has to rise at least 3 pips. Even so, your profit will always be 2 pips less than what it should be. So, because of this system, I always open a position and always float the loss, even sometimes the opening price and the current price are at the same level. Not surprising! But at least they have found a legitimate way to profit from their users as long as they don't take away your money with a scam program, I think I should be fine with profiting from the pips or commision or anything as long it's transparent to me. And I can say Neither raw nor standard account, as long as you get more profit than the pips they cut, you will be profitable.
Michael

Jan 2 2023

Angela Thomas: Yes! That's the point I have been thinking. If the charged even 2-3 pips it will not affecting to our trade too much because the price can rises and drops very quickly even with one move, they can rises and drops more than 3 pips. Neither is RAW spread or not, we need to patient and just careful to understand the spread's of the pair that we trade. You need to take profit more than pips!
Soliano Alejandro

Jan 10 2024

So, I'm trying to wrap my head around this whole market price thing from the article. As a newbie, it sounds like the article's nudging me towards a standard account. But then it throws in this curveball about the market price having some added fees in the standard account, while the raw spread keeps it real with no extra charges. Now, I'm kinda feeling let down by the standard account. Like, is it normal for them to jack up prices in there? And what's the deal with this market price the article's talking about? And, yo, is it even legal for them to hike up prices when they're supposed to be regulated?

Tommy Ke

Jan 14 2024

Hey, I can break down your queries for you:

  • 1. Do standard accounts typically have higher prices?
    Totally, it's pretty standard for standard accounts to jack up their prices a bit. They often throw in extra fees, which might not sit well with everyone. And just so you know, even those raw accounts aren't entirely fee-free; they sometimes hit you with commission fees.
  • 2. What's up with that market price the article talks about?
    The article's market price is basically the standard rate for the item or asset you're dealing with. But here's the catch: in standard accounts, they might pad that price with some extra costs. For instance, imagine you're into stock trading, and a single share's market price is $100. In a standard account, they could slap on extra charges, like commissions, pushing that price up to, let's say, $105. (read : How To Choose Broker's Fees)
  • 3. Can brokers legally inflate their prices if they're under regulation?
    Well, brokers usually operate under some regulations, keeping them in check. But it's essential to dive into the specific guidelines of the regulatory body overseeing them. While some price increases might be permissible, they can't be up to any sketchy business.